Your Breathalyzer Test Results Might Be Inaccurate

by | Feb 3, 2022 | DWI

A breath test result over 0.08 can feel like the end of your case. Many people charged with DWI assume a number on a printout means a conviction is certain. That isn’t always true.

Breath testing machines are only as reliable as their maintenance, the officer running the test, and the person being tested. A New York Times investigation found that breathalyzer results can be inaccurate because of poor calibration, software problems, and human error. Courts in some states threw out thousands of results as a result.

Here are the most common reasons a breath test may not reflect your true level of intoxication, and what that means for your Texas DWI case.

Problems With the Machine

Texas uses the Intoxilyzer 9000 for official breath tests after an arrest. Like any instrument, it can fail. Common problems include:

  • Calibration errors: if the machine isn’t regularly checked against a known alcohol standard, its readings can drift.
  • Missed maintenance: state rules require a technical supervisor to regularly inspect and maintain each instrument.
  • Software or hardware failures: error messages, failed self-checks, or past repair problems can raise doubts about a result.
  • Radio interference: electronic signals from radios or phones can affect some instruments.

Your attorney can request the maintenance, calibration, and repair records for the specific machine used in your test.

Mistakes by the Officer

Texas has strict rules for how evidentiary breath tests must be given. Mistakes can make a result unreliable, including:

  • No proper observation period: the officer must watch you for at least 15 minutes before the test to make sure you don’t burp, vomit, eat, drink, or smoke. Any of these can bring alcohol from your stomach back into your mouth.
  • Expired certification: the operator must hold a current state certification.
  • Samples that don’t agree: you must give two samples, and they must be close enough to each other.
  • Wrong technique: the instructions given to you can affect how you blow, and that can affect the reading.

These rules apply to the official test at the station. The handheld test given at the roadside is less reliable and generally can’t be used in court to prove your BAC. Learn more about the difference between roadside PBTs and evidentiary breath tests.

“Mouth Alcohol” and Medical Conditions

Breath tests are designed to measure alcohol from deep in your lungs, not alcohol sitting in your mouth. Several things can cause falsely high readings:

  • Acid reflux or GERD: stomach contents, including alcohol, can rise into the mouth and throat.
  • Recent drinking: alcohol from your last drink may still be in your mouth.
  • Mouthwash, breath spray, or cough syrup: many contain alcohol.
  • Dental work: dentures, bridges, or braces can trap alcohol.
  • Diabetes, low-carb diets, or fasting: these can raise acetone levels in your breath, and some machines may read acetone as alcohol.

Workplace and Chemical Exposure

People who work around paint, varnish, cleaning solvents, fuel, or industrial chemicals may have compounds in their breath that interfere with testing. Heavy use of alcohol-based hand sanitizer right before a test may also be worth looking into.

Rising Blood Alcohol

Your body keeps absorbing alcohol for some time after your last drink. If you took the test well after you were pulled over, your BAC may have been lower while you were driving than when you were tested. The law cares about your BAC while you were driving, not at the station.

What This Means for Your DWI Case

If there are problems with your breath test, your attorney may:

  • File a motion to suppress: ask the court to exclude a result that wasn’t obtained according to Texas rules
  • Challenge the result at trial: use cross-examination and expert witnesses
  • Use weak test evidence in negotiations: push for a reduced charge or a dismissal
  • Contest your ALR suspension: you typically have only 15 days from your arrest to request this hearing. Learn more about DWI license suspension and revocation in Texas.

A breath test is just one piece of evidence. The prosecution still has to prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt.

Talk to a Longview DWI Attorney

If you’re facing a DWI charge based on a breath test, don’t assume the number is final. Attorney Ryan R. Hill can review the testing records, look for errors, and build your defense. Learn more about our Longview DWI defense services, or call 903-551-6172 for a free consultation.